Class 10 · Democratic Politics II · Chapter 5

Outcomes of Democracy

Every section of the chapter in one sentence, with the key terms highlighted. Turn on Test me to hide the highlighted words, then tap each blank to check yourself. The cartoons, graphs and tables are taken from the chapter PDF; tap any picture to enlarge it.

One line per section

1

How do we assess democracy's outcomes?

We ask what democracy does and whether it meets our expectations in five areas: quality of government, economic well-being, inequality, social differences and conflict, and freedom and dignity.

Cartoon: Is democracy all about coping with multiple pressures and accommodating diverse demands? (© RK Laxman)
1.1

Why democracy is better

From Madam Lyngdoh's class (Class IX), democracy is better than dictatorship because it promotes equality among citizens, enhances the dignity of the individual, improves the quality of decision-making, provides a method to resolve conflicts and allows room to correct mistakes.

1.2

Good in principle, not so good in practice

Most people support democracy over rule by a monarch, military or religious leaders, yet few are satisfied with it in practice; this dilemma makes us ask whether we prefer democracy only for moral reasons or also for prudential reasons; over a hundred countries practise some kind of democracy (constitutions, elections, parties, rights), though they differ socially, economically and culturally.

1.3

Democracy is just a form of government

Democracy cannot solve every socio-economic and political problem; it is just a form of government that can only create conditions for achieving goals, and citizens have to take advantage of those conditions.

2

Accountable, responsive and legitimate government

People should have the right to choose their rulers and control over the rulers, so the most basic outcome of democracy is a government that is accountable to the citizens and responsive to their needs and expectations.

2.1

Is democratic government efficient?

Non-democratic rulers decide quickly because they ignore assemblies and public opinion, while democracy is based on deliberation and negotiation, so some delay happens; but decisions taken after following procedures are more acceptable and more effective, so the cost of time is worth it.

2.2

Transparency

Democratic decisions follow norms and procedures, and a citizen has the right and the means to examine the process of decision making; this is called transparency, often missing in a non-democratic government.

Cartoon: Governmental Secrecy (© Mike Keefe, Cagle Cartoons)
2.3

How to measure this outcome

Look for regular, free and fair elections, open public debate on major policies and laws, and citizens' right to information; the record is mixed: good at regular free elections and open debate, weak at giving everyone a fair chance and at sharing information, but still much better than non-democratic regimes.

2.4

Responsive and free of corruption?

We expect a government attentive to people's needs and largely free of corruption, but democracies' record here is not impressive: they often ignore the demands of the majority and are not free of corruption; still, non-democracies are not less corrupt or more sensitive.

2.5

Legitimate government

Democracy is certainly better in one way: it is legitimate government, people's own government, even if slow or less clean; South Asian surveys show overwhelming support for democracy, even where it is absent, and democracy's ability to generate its own support is itself an outcome.

Graphs: Support for democracy in South Asia (SDSA survey, 2007): democracy preferred over dictatorship everywhere except Pakistan; suitable for own country (South Asia 88); rule by elected leaders (South Asia 94)
3

Economic growth and development

Over 1950–2000, dictatorships had a slightly higher rate of economic growth, but growth depends on population size, global situation, cooperation from other countries and economic priorities; between poor countries the difference is negligible, so democracy is not a guarantee of development but should not lag behind dictatorships, and it has other positive outcomes.

Cartoon: The Rich Get Buff: economic growth and income distribution gains, 2000–2006 (© RJ Matson, Cagle Cartoons)
3.1

Economic outcomes of democracy: the evidence

Table 1: growth rate of all democracies 3.95 vs all dictatorships 4.42, but poor dictatorships 4.34 vs poor democracies 4.28 (virtually no difference); Table 2: in South Africa and Brazil the top 20% take over 60% of national income and the bottom 20% get under 3%, while Denmark and Hungary are much more equal.

Table 1: Rates of economic growth, 1950–2000 · Table 2: Inequality of income in selected countries
Cartoon: Poor Kids: housing, health care, schooling, hunger (© Jimmy Margulies, Cagle Cartoons)
4

Reduction of inequality and poverty

Democracies are based on political equality (equal weight in electing representatives), yet economic inequalities are growing: a small number of ultra-rich hold a highly disproportionate share of wealth that keeps rising, while the poorest struggle for food, clothing, house, education and health.

Cartoon: Voice of the Poor (© Ares, Cagle Cartoons)
Cartoon: World's Wealth Owned by a Few (© Manny Francisco, Cagle Cartoons)
4.1

Democracy and poverty

Democracies are not very successful in reducing economic inequalities; the poor are a large proportion of voters, yet elected governments are not as keen to address poverty as expected; in Bangladesh more than half the people live in poverty, and several poor countries depend on rich countries even for food.

5

Accommodation of social diversity

Democracy should produce a harmonious social life: like Belgium, democracies develop a procedure to conduct their competition, which stops tensions turning explosive or violent; no society can fully resolve conflicts, but democracy helps respect differences and negotiate them, whereas non-democracies turn a blind eye to or suppress them.

Cartoons: Enemies and Greeting: two kinds of effects democratic politics can have on social divisions (© Ares, Cagle Cartoons)
5.1

Two conditions (lesson of Sri Lanka)

First, democracy is not simply rule by majority opinion: the majority must work with the minority, and majority and minority opinions are not permanent; second, rule by majority must not become rule by majority community (religion, race, language), because democracy stays democracy only while every citizen has a chance of being in majority; anyone barred by birth is not accommodated.

6

Dignity and freedom of the citizens

Democracy is much superior to any other government in promoting the dignity and freedom of the individual; the passion for respect and freedom is the basis of democracy, though societies built on subordination and domination find equality hard to accept.

6.1

Dignity of women

Most societies were male dominated, but long struggles by women made respect and equal treatment of women part of democracy; once the principle is recognised, women can fight what is now unacceptable legally and morally, which would have no legal basis in a non-democracy.

6.2

Caste inequalities

Democracy in India has strengthened the claims of disadvantaged and discriminated castes for equal status and equal opportunity; caste atrocities still happen but they lack moral and legal foundations.

Cartoon: Rosa Parks Still Inspires (© Pat Bagley, Cagle Cartoons)
6.3

An examination that never gets over

Expectations are the criteria for judging democracy, and its examination never gets over: as it passes one test, people ask for more; complaining is itself a testimony to its success, because it transforms people from subjects into citizens, and most people believe their vote makes a difference.

Graph: Those who say their vote makes a difference: South Asia 65, Bangladesh 66, India 67, Nepal 75, Pakistan 50, Sri Lanka 65 (SDSA, 2007)
Poster: How to cast your vote using EVM and VVPAT (Election Commission of India)

Five outcomes in one table

OutcomeWhat we expectWhat democracy deliversWhere it falls short
GovernmentAccountable, responsive, legitimate; transparent decisionsRegular free elections, open public debate, transparency; legitimate "people's own" government with overwhelming supportSlow (deliberation); unfair chances in elections; poor at sharing information; corruption; ignores majority demands
Economic growthDevelopment, at least as good as dictatorshipsAmong poor countries growth is nearly equal (4.28 vs 4.34)Dictatorships slightly faster overall, 1950–2000 (4.42 vs 3.95); no guarantee of development
Inequality & povertyFair distribution of wealth and opportunitiesPolitical equality: one person, equal weight in electionsUltra-rich share keeps rising; poor ignored though they are many voters; Bangladesh: over half poor
Social diversityPeaceful, harmonious social lifeProcedures for competition; respects and negotiates differences (Belgium)Fails if majority becomes permanent or a majority community rules (Sri Lanka)
Dignity & freedomRespect and freedom for every individualLegal and moral backing for women and disadvantaged castes; subjects become citizensDiscrimination and caste atrocities still happen in practice

Memory tricks

5 outcome areas (chapter order)G-E-I-S-D

"Good Eggs Is Sunday Dinner": Government, Economic growth, Inequality & poverty, Social diversity, Dignity & freedom.

Why democracy is betterE-D-Q-C-M

"Every Dog Quietly Chews Mangoes": Equality, Dignity, Quality of decisions, Conflict resolution, Mistakes corrected.

Basic outcomeA-R-L

Accountable, Responsive, Legitimate: "A Real Leader". Only L is a clear win over dictatorship.

How to measure itE-D-I

Elections (regular, free, fair), open public Debate, right to Information. Good at E and D, weak at I.

TransparencySee the process

Transparency = the citizen's right and means to examine the process of decision making. Opposite of the "Governmental Secrecy" cartoon.

Table 1 growth rates3.95 · 4.42

All democracies 3.95, all dictatorships 4.42. Poor countries: dictatorship 4.34 vs democracy 4.28, almost a tie ("the 4.3 tie").

Table 2 inequality60 / 3

South Africa & Brazil: top 20% take over 60%, bottom 20% get under 3%. Denmark & Hungary: about 34 / 10.

Factors in growthP-G-C-P

Population size, Global situation, Cooperation from other countries, economic Priorities: "Pizza Gets Cold Personally".

Social diversity conditions2 × "not"

Majority is not permanent (works with minority) and not a community (religion, race, language). Lesson: Sri Lanka; model: Belgium.

Survey numbers (South Asia)94 · 88 · 65

94 want rule by elected leaders, 88 find democracy suitable, 65 say their vote makes a difference. Pakistan is lowest each time.

Dignity examplesW + C

Women and Caste: once the principle is recognised, discrimination loses its legal and moral base.

Big ideaSubject → Citizen

Complaints show success: democracy's "exam" never ends, and it turns a subject into a citizen.

Nannu's RTI story (Exercise 8): read it as a timeline

Jan 2004Nannu, a daily wage earner in Welcome Mazdoor Colony (East Delhi), loses his ration card and applies for a duplicate.
3 monthsRounds to the Food and Civil Supplies office; clerks ignore him.
RTIHe files an application under the Right to Information Act asking for progress, officials' names and action against them.
1 weekAn inspector visits: the card is ready.
Next dayThe Food and Supply Officer offers him tea and asks him to withdraw the RTI application.

Lesson: the right to information makes government accountable and responsive; ordinary citizens can make officials act.

Democracy vs dictatorship, point by point

Speed of decisionsDictatorship faster; democracy slower because of deliberation and negotiation, but its decisions are more acceptable and effective.
TransparencyDemocracy: citizens can examine the process. Dictatorship: often missing.
Corruption & responsivenessDemocracy's record not impressive, but non-democracies are no less corrupt or more sensitive.
LegitimacyDemocracy clearly better: people's own government.
Economic growthDictatorships slightly higher overall (4.42 vs 3.95); negligible gap in poor countries.
Social differencesDemocracy negotiates them; non-democracies ignore or suppress them.
Dignity & freedomDemocracy much superior: gives legal and moral force to equal treatment.

Only economic growth tilts (slightly) towards dictatorship; everywhere else democracy is equal or better.

Flashcards

Say the answer out loud first, then tap to check.

Quick quiz

First three are the textbook MCQs (Exercises 5–7).

Revision plan

Day 1

Read the one-liners aloud twice. Then turn on Test me and fill the blanks.

Day 2

Write the five-outcomes table from memory on blank paper. Check and fix in red.

Day 4

Flashcards + quiz. Re-read only the sections you missed.

Day 7

Explain "democracy vs dictatorship" to someone in 5 minutes without looking.

Day 14

Answer textbook Exercises 1–4 and Nannu's passage using the key terms.

Map method

On a blank South Asia outline map, write the survey numbers beside each country: "vote makes a difference" (Nepal 75, India 67, Bangladesh 66, Sri Lanka 65, Pakistan 50). Mark Belgium (accommodation works) and Sri Lanka (majority community rule) on a world map.

Memory palace

Walk through your home: the door is the government that opens to citizens (A-R-L), the living room holds the growth tables (3.95 vs 4.42), the kitchen is the world's-wealth cake (inequality), the dining table seats Belgium and Sri Lanka (diversity), and the balcony is Rosa Parks and the vote (dignity).

Blurting

Close the book, set a 5-minute timer and write every key term and number you remember. The gaps show you what to revise.